The Impact of Grading Companies on Ichor Elixir Value for MTG

In TCG ·

Ichor Elixir MTG card art

Image courtesy of Scryfall.com

Grading, Value, and the Curious Case of Ichor Elixir

Grading companies have quietly become a central gatekeeper in the Magic: The Gathering marketplace. PSA, BGS, SGC, and others promise consistency, authenticity, and a number on a scale that players and collectors use as a proxy for “how nice is this card?” When you pair that with a modern Commander-era artifact like Ichor Elixir, the conversation shifts from “Does this card work in a deck?” to “What is this copy worth if it’s pristine, slabbed, and widely recognized as mint?” 🧙‍♂️🔥 In a world where a card’s price can swing on a whisper of supply and demand, grading adds another axis to the chart of value—sometimes tipping the scales, sometimes barely moving the needle. ⚔️

Ichor Elixir is a rare artifact from the March of the Machine Commander set, originally released in 2023. Its mana cost sits at four generic mana, and its ability centers on the Planar dice mechanic—a thematic nod to the omniversal chaos that Commander players often embrace. The card’s text reads simply: “If you would roll one or more planar dice, instead roll that many planar dice plus one and ignore one. {T}: Add {C}{C}.” The loop is elegant: you invest in the artifact, then you amplify your planar-dice outcomes while still generating colorless mana. Its color identity is empty, which makes it flexible in primarily mono- or colorless stacks. This kind of design—a reliable, nonland mana payoff with a quirky dice interaction—fits a Commander table where art, flavor, and tactical nuance matter as much as raw power. 🧭

From a grading perspective, what you’re paying for in a modern, non-foil rare from a Commander set is condition, centering, and surface integrity. A typical print run for MOС (March of the Machine Commander) cards means many copies circulate in sleeves and boxes, and the market price for Ichor Elixir sits modestly around a few dimes to a few dollars in raw form. In fact, current market data reflects a USD price around 0.17, with euro equivalents hovering around the same order of magnitude. That baseline makes the prospect of bringing the price up significantly via a professional grade more of a question of perceived value and liquidity than raw power. Still, if you’ve got a pristine, unplayed copy—or a misprint, or a notable error—that could push a grade into a premium tier, especially for a collector who wants to showcase a neat Chuck Norris of a dice mechanic on their shelf. 💎

Grading is most telling for cards with robust demand, limited print runs, or iconic status. Ichor Elixir isn’t an ultra-staple in competitive formats, and its use-case in tabletop decks is more niche than, say, a versatile mana dial or a classic commander staple. That doesn’t mean grading has no value; it simply means buyers should calibrate expectations. For a modern artifact priced well under a couple dollars in raw condition, the cost of grading—plus shipping, plus potential turnaround times—may not be recouped in a sale, unless you hold a handful of high-graded copies from a sought-after subset or you’re curating a showcase collection. In practice, many players approach grading with an eye toward long-term liquidity and the thrill of owning a slab that gleams like a tiny trophy on the shelf. 🧙‍♀️🎲

There’s another layer, too: the design and lore surrounding Ichor Elixir. The flavor text ties into a larger Phyrexian mythos—“The corrupted essence of Kaldheim's World Tree became the seed from which New Phyrexia's Realmbreaker grew.” This kind of storytelling enriches the card’s aura for collectors who savor the intersection of MTG lore and card function. Warren Mahy’s art for Ichor Elixir captures an atmospherically eerie, almost alchemical vibe that resonates with the “artifact-as-art” crowd. In grading conversations, such narrative weight can amplify perceived value; a mint condition piece featuring evocative art becomes more than a card—it becomes a vignette from the multiverse. 🎨🧪

As a practical note for players and collectors, consider mixing playability with collectability. If you’re eyeing Ichor Elixir as a party-piece for Planeswalker-heavy or Planar-dice builds, you’re buying into a deck archetype that values unique interactions and memorable moments at the table. The ability itself—a nod to the dice-centric flavor of the set—can shine in a commander environment where dice results become storybeats at the table. If you’re chasing a grade, don’t forget the physical realities: grading requires sending the card to a service, awaiting grading windows, and paying fees that vary by service level. For many modern artifacts, the math will favor play rather than pristine display. Still, for the right copy, a high grade can unlock a premium in secondary markets and convert a “nice card” into a true centerpiece. ⚔️

On a desk near a monitor, a quality slab can be a conversation starter and a reminder of where the hobby’s value comes from: a shared love of strategy, art, and the never-ending hunt for the perfect card. And if you’re looking to keep the rest of your workspace on-brand while you chase those moments of MTG memory, you might reach for a little desk gear from a trusted retailer—like a neon rectangular mouse pad that keeps your mouse in place as you track card prices, trades, and tournaments. The world of grading is big, but the table where you play it is bigger. 🧙‍♂️🔥💎

Neon Rectangle Mouse Pad – Ultra-Thin 1.58mm Rubber Base

More from our network