Image courtesy of Scryfall.com

Stonecloaker: Foil vs Etched Foil Valuation

Stonecloaker is a delightful little tempo creature from Time Spiral Remastered that wears its white-magic personality on its sleeve: Flash and Flying, a sturdy 3/2 body, and two powerful in-EETB effects. For players chasing value, the question often comes down to one thing: how does the foil treatment—especially the oft-misunderstood etched foil—affect the card’s value, usability, and long-term collectability? 🧙‍♂️🔥💎

In its baseline form, Stonecloaker costs 2W and arrives as a white creature with two sharp advantages. First, Flash lets you surprise block or block-and-bounce in the same moment, keeping your opponent guessing. Second, Flying gives it reach against ground-based offenses and helps it survive early pressure. The ceaseless optimism of a white tempo card shines through: when it enters, you may return a creature you control to its owner's hand, a classic tempo engine that buys you space to develop your board while keeping your options open. And as a bonus ETB, Stonecloaker exiles a target card from a graveyard, which can slow down players who rely on their graveyard for value or recursion. It’s the little touches that make this common-but-potent gem feel timeless. 🧙‍♂️⚔️

From a mechanical perspective, the card’s presence in Time Spiral Remastered (tsr) underscores how Wizards of the Coast leaned into reprints that preserved the nostalgic feel while giving modern players a chance to wield past power with updated production. The TSR printing is a Masters-era release, which tends to attract both longtime collectors and newer players who enjoy the feel of vintage design with current print spark. Stonecloaker’s blend of tempo and graveyard disruption scales nicely in Commander and even finds a place in certain Modern or Legacy shells that care about ETB effects or graveyard hate. The set’s magic, in this case, is in how a 3/2 flier can turn mundane turns into strategic swings—playing into opponent misreads and sparkly foil shine. 🎨

Pricing reality: foil vs nonfoil

Market data for the TSR Stonecloaker shows a clear premium on foil finishes. The current USD price for the foil print sits around $0.70, versus roughly $0.14 for the nonfoil. That fivefold premium isn’t unusual for an uncommon card from a Masters-era reprint, where the foil run tends to be smaller and the demand from collectors and players who want a little extra shine remains healthy. In euro terms, foil is about €0.68, while nonfoil hovers near €0.17, illustrating a broadly similar premium across major markets. This kind of delta—especially for a card that sees occasional play in Commander and Modern—highlights how collectors value the aesthetic and the historical footprint of the piece as much as its gameplay power. 💎🔥

But the conversation grows more nuanced when you introduce the etched foil variant into the mix. Etched foils are a distinct foil treatment that tends to produce a more subdued, frosted look with a different texture. They’re often produced in limited runs and can become highly collectible, sometimes fetching premium well beyond traditional foils in the right market window. In Stonecloaker’s dataset, there isn’t a listed etched-foil price: "usd_etched" is not provided, which suggests either that an etched foil TSR printing isn’t widely tracked in this dataset or that it wasn’t broadly released for this card. In practice, etched foils can attract premium valuations, but the exact figure varies with supply, demand, and how aggressively a given retailer or market segment promotes the variant. The takeaway: etched foils can swing value, but you’ll want to watch market chatter and price tracking to know when the premium shows up for a card like Stonecloaker. 🧩⚔️

Beyond pure price, you should weigh the card’s playable presence. Stonecloaker is Modern-legal and legacy-friendly, with a Commander audience that appreciates flexible ETB effects and graveyard interaction. Its EDHREC rank sits in a respectable range for a niche white control piece, signaling that while it isn’t a racecar in every deck, it has targeted, lasting appeal. For collectors, the TSR variant adds a layer of history to the card—a reminder of a beloved era of Magic design and a time when reprints were carefully curated to celebrate the game’s past. This dual identity—playable power plus collector prestige—helps explain why valuations for foil and etched variants can diverge over time. 🧙‍♂️💎

From a practical standpoint, how should you approach valuation if you’re eyeing a Stonecloaker foil or etched foil? Start with a baseline: the foil price currently sits around $0.70 USD; the nonfoil sits around $0.14 USD. If you’re chasing a premium etched variant, prepare for variability and potentially limited availability; prices may swing with new printings, market surges, or notable Commander combos that bring ETB effects back into the spotlight. Always compare multiple marketplaces—TCGplayer, CardMarket, and others—and consider the card’s supply in your region, since local demand can tilt prices more than global numbers. And when you’re stacking these values, remember that the card’s true strength for collectors is the blend of art, history, and the tactile joy of a foil or etched foil surface that stands out on the shelf. 🧙‍♂️🔥💎

In the end, Stonecloaker offers a compact, flavorful package: tempo versatility, graveyard disruption, and a foil finish that can shine in a display case as much as in a duel. For the serious collector, the foil variant provides a clear value proposition, while etched foil remains a whispered opportunity—worth monitoring if you like chasing the rare and the shimmering. And if you’re balancing hobby dollars with real-world gear, a quick reminder: when you’re done weighing valuations, you can always treat yourself to something as vibrant as this article’s spirit—like a neon smartphone case that keeps your device safe and stylish while you draft your next Stonecloaker moment. 🔥🎲

More from our network

• https://crypto-acolytes.xyz/blog/post/nft-stats-yumeiro-92-from-yumeiro-collection/
• https://wiki.digital-vault.xyz/wiki/post/pokemon-tcg-stats-tropius-card-id-bw10-5/
• https://blog.zero-static.xyz/blog/post/pactdoll-terror-a-deep-dive-into-its-original-lore/
• https://wiki.digital-vault.xyz/wiki/post/pokemon-tcg-stats-aron-card-id-dp2-71/
• https://crypto-acolytes.xyz/blog/post/uncover-hidden-realms-the-magic-of-secret-quests/