Image courtesy of Scryfall.com

Holy Justiciar: Community Contest Deckbuilding for Commander

Community contests and themed deck challenges have always been the heartbeat of how we connect with Magic: The Gathering beyond the shop shelves and tournament floors. They push us to think in new colors, embrace quirks, and celebrate the idea that a single card can spark a thousand storylines. When you lean into a theme with your friends, you’re not just building a deck—you’re crafting a shared memory. In that spirit, a classic white card from the Avacyn Restored era—Holy Justiciar—offers a fantastic, flavorful anchor for a Commander deck built around mercy, disruption, and a little bit of undead-smiting mojo. 🧙‍♂️🔥💎

This unassuming uncommon from Avacyn Restored is a 4-mana white creature with a practical, no-nonsense ability: "{2}{W}, {T}: Tap target creature. If that creature is a Zombie, exile it." It’s not flashy like a finisher, but it brings tempo, removal flexibility, and a dash of thematic justice to the table. In Commander, where every tap matters and Zombie-centric decks are a perennial presence, Holy Justiciar offers a reliable way to deselect the battlefield—especially when that battlefield hosts the undead. The flavor text—“Her eyes see through the rotting flesh and glimpse a soul in agony, begging for the Blessed Sleep.”—helps you frame a narrative: mercy with teeth, judgment without haste. ⚔️🎨

A centerpiece for white control and zombie-hunting builds

White control in Commander thrives on precise, efficient answers and a calm, patient game plan. Holy Justiciar slots neatly into decks that want to slow the pace, pick off threats, and punish opponent boards that lean on zombies or recursion. You’re not trying to race a dragon with this card; you’re trying to prune the adversary’s options and keep your own board healthy. The requirement to tap a creature to exile it (if it’s a Zombie) also encourages a strategic preference for white removal and exile effects, pairing nicely with other hands-off disruptions like or Swords to Plowshares in a diverse five-player environment. And yes, it scales with Commander—where even a 2/1 creature can anchor a plan when protected by layering removal, bounce, and protective auras. 🧙‍♂️⚔️

• Tempo-friendly control: use Holy Justiciar to stall key threats while you assemble answers and a late-game plan.
• Zombie-hunting subtheme: a built-in incentive to include Zombie light or Zombie-swarming decks in the metagame, creating inter-player interactions that are both thematic and strategic.
• White disruption stack: pair with early-board stabilizers like selfless cards and bounce effects to keep threats off the board without overcommitting to removal.
• Citizen/cleric synergy (thematic): lean into white's discipline and protective vibe—life gain, board control, and spell-slinging integrity.
• Budget-friendly entry point: Holy Justiciar’s rarity and price point make it a practical centerpiece for a contest deck without breaking the bank. The card also looks good in foil, which is a nice collectable touch for a flavorful build.

Themed deck ideas you can test in community challenges

Here are a few angles you can lean into when drafting for a themed contest. Each keeps Holy Justiciar in the lead role while inviting flavorful twists. 🧩

• Mercy and Judgment—A white control shell that leans into mercy as a tactic: exile threats, protect life totals, and justify the slow, deliberate control plan with a clear narrative arc. Include angels and other justice-focused creatures to reinforce the theme.
• Zombie Subversion—A matchup-driven theme where zombies proliferate on one side of the table, and you wield targeted exile to carve them away. Your strategy can be less about outright removing every zombie and more about controlling the timing of crucial exiles.
• Temple of the Blessed—A lore-forward build that pairs Holy Justiciar with flavorful white-stax elements and flavor-accurate story moments from the Avacyn Restored era. Use this as a narrative deck that invites discussion and storytelling at the table. 🧙‍♂️
• Tempo Angels—A subset where you combine white creature-based control with efficient threats and a couple of resilient angels for finishers. Holy Justiciar keeps the board in check while you push through with a few white beaters.
• Exile Matters—Blue and White Fusion—If your playgroup enjoys cross-color synergies, pair Holy Justiciar with a splash of blue for additional countermagic and targeted exile shenanigans, crafting a theme around “mercy through controlled magic.”

Flavor, lore, and art as driving forces

One of the joys of building around a card like Holy Justiciar is the art and the story it evokes. David Rapoza’s illustration captures that stern, compassionate zeal—the calm authority of a cleric who chooses exile only when necessary, and only against the right kind of threat. That tension is ripe for narrative decks: you can tell a story about the Blessed Sleep and the weight of judgment, weaving in flavor notes from Avacyn Restored’s gothic, radiant aesthetics. The old-school border and classic frame remind us of a time when magic was a little grim, a little hopeful, and always ready to spark a vivid table-side tale. 🎨💎

From a design perspective, Holy Justiciar demonstrates how a simple efficiency tool—tap a creature—can ripple into broader strategic space. It’s a gentle reminder that not every white staple needs to be a big flashy finisher; sometimes the best tool is the one that buys you an extra turn to set up your plan, protects your life total, and keeps a Zombie threat from reanimating in the next upkeep. It’s exactly the sort of card that makes community contests feel both nostalgic and fresh. ⚔️

Collectors, value, and card authenticity

As an Avacyn Restored uncommon, Holy Justiciar sits in an approachable price tier for most players, with modest foil appeal. Its modern and vintage playability reflects its lasting utility in Commander, legacy, and duel environments. If you’re a player who loves to blend tabletop strategy with a touch of collectible pride, you’ll appreciate the foil and nonfoil finishes that showcase the artwork while remaining playable in formats where it’s legal. The card’s EDHREC relevance sits modestly high enough to be recognized by theme-focused decks, making it a nice centerpiece for a community deck-building showcase. 🧙‍♂️💎

Whether you’re entering a local contest or just cooking up a themed night at your LGS, Holy Justiciar offers a sturdy, flavorful axis around which to build a memorable deck. And if you’re curious to explore more on the broader MTG community—or want to see how other outlets discuss community-driven formats—our five linked reads below offer a taste of the wider network’s ideas. 🔥🎲

More from our network

• Why new players should try Guild Wars 2 on PC today
• Decoding subtext in Architect of the Untamed's flavor
• Kamino Solana meme coin shows on-chain momentum surge
• Support AI safety and alignment research for a safer future
• Pokemon TCG stats: Seadra card ID EX15-22