Cruel Feeding Across Sets: Longitudinal MTG Performance

In TCG ·

Cruel Feeding card art from Journey into Nyx

Image courtesy of Scryfall.com

Tracking Cruel Feeding Across Sets

Black instant spells rarely arrive with a wink and a nod from the mechanics department, but Cruel Feeding does more than just deliver a bit of lifelink-y life swing. Born in Journey into Nyx as a common rarity, this {B} spell introduces Strive—an elegant cost-adjustment mechanic that scales with the number of targets. The end result is a versatile tool that rewards players who can marshal multiple creatures at once, transforming a humble one‑manacost into a budget-friendly, multi-target payoff. In practice, you pay one mana for the first target, then 2 colorless for each additional target you choose to buff. The payoff? +1/+0 for each target and lifelink, until end of turn. That lifelink converts your gains into sustained momentum, especially in creature-heavy boards where every swing is a potential life swing. 🧙‍♂️🔥

The card’s lore and design live at the intersection of Nyx’s shadowy aesthetics and practical battlefield utility. In a world where creatures come and go, Cruel Feeding reminds us that real power often arrives in numbers. The text reads plainly, but its implications ripple through deck-building decisions. You’re not simply buffing a single creature; you’re orchestrating a micro-army buff that can turn small dorks into a lifelinking front line, or give a big, risky lifelink push to end a race. The lifelink clause matters: when damage and life gain occur simultaneously, you’re turning every combat step into a possible drip-feed of lifetotal advantage. And with Strive, your investment scales, turning a minimal one-mana investment into a dramatic, multi-target moment if you have the bodies to back it up. 🧩

Historical snapshot: Journey into Nyx and the Strive era

Released in 2014 as part of the Journey into Nyx expansion, Cruel Feeding sits in a block that leaned into the mythic flavor of Theros while introducing modernized keywords. Strive, the mechanic that powers Cruel Feeding, debuted as a way to reward players for investing in multiple targets. The card’s color identity is Black, matching the set’s moody, life-drain vibe. Although it’s a common card, its presence in a multi-target lifelink pill can be deceptively potent in the right shell—particularly in Commander where your ability to keep a board-wide lifelink buffer alive matters more than raw one-shot damage. In formats where you can maximize the number of targets, Cruel Feeding becomes a quiet workhorse, not flashy, but consistently reliable in the right circumstances. The rarity and print run keep it accessible for budget-minded players who still want to experiment with Strive as a design concept. 💎

Where it shows up across formats and sets

Across sets, Cruel Feeding tends to appear in decks that lean on multiple creatures, lifelink synergies, or cumulative buffs. In Modern and Legacy, it’s not typically a cornerstone, but it can slot into a toolbox of black control and midrange strategies that want a temporary, high-density buff for a swing. In Commander, the card tends to shine most when you’re running a board with a handful of lifelink creatures or tokens, where every extra target adds a quantum of value. The timeless lesson here is that Strive scales well in casual, multi-player settings where a few extra lifelink hits can swing the life total and control the pace of the game. For collectors, Cruel Feeding’s common status keeps it affordable, yet the card remains a fond reminder of how a small spell can influence big moments when played at the right tempo. 🔥

Deck-building notes and practical play tips

  • Target-rich boards shine with Strive: The more creatures you can legally target, the more value Cruel Feeding yields. If you’re slamming five or more targets, you’re likely turning the exchange in your favor, especially if your board state already includes lifelink or damage-to-life conversions. 🧙‍♂️
  • Discounts and timing: With the base cost of {B} and incremental costs, you can save mana by layering targets strategically. If you’re in a position to cast for the first target and hold up mana for the rest, you preserve tempo and threaten a blowout that opponents must deal with immediately.
  • Complementary synergies: Pair Cruel Feeding with black sources that generate incremental advantage or life gain triggers. When lifelink is involved, even small lifelinkers become meaningful contributors in long grindy games, and you’ll see life totals swing in your favor as your gains compound. 🧭
  • Commander-friendly roles: In EDH, the spell slots into boards with a mix of evasive or sturdy lifelink creatures. It’s less about one massive swing and more about creating a momentum shift that tilts fights in your direction over multiple turns.
  • Budget value: At roughly four cents in the USD market (as tracked by price aggregators), Cruel Feeding remains an approachable choice for new players exploring the Strive mechanic without breaking the bank. Foils remain a touch pricier, and the etched variants bring a dash of shine for collectors. ⚔️
“Strive turns a small spell into a chorus of lifelings,” as one seasoned writer once noted—the kind of design flourish that rewards players who plan multi-target outcomes rather than chasing a single, dramatic play. 🎨

Art, design, and cultural vibes

Jason A. Engle’s art for Cruel Feeding captures a moody, shadow-laced vibe that fits nicely with Nyx’s underworldly palette. The card’s visual storytelling complements its mechanical message: a lean spell that, when multiplied, can swing the tide. The black mana symbol and the lifelink theme echo a culture of careful, sometimes grim, efficiency—perfect for players who enjoy the elegance of a well-timed lifegain spike. The art direction, much like the block’s broader aesthetic, leans into a mythic vibe that resonates with long-time fans who remember Nyx’s mythic coin flips and heroic undertones. 🎲

Market pulse and collector value

As a common rarity with a straightforward, repeatable effect, Cruel Feeding remains a practical, under-the-radar pick for budget-conscious players and curious experimenters. Current price estimates hover around a few cents for non-foil copies, with foils nudging higher. While it may not fetch lofty collector premiums, its enduring utility in multi-target lifelink setups keeps it relevant for modern tabletop play and casual Magic gatherings. For those curious about broader value, Scryfall’s pricing helps track shifts as formats shift and new strategies emerge, underscoring how even a modest card can sustain a lasting foothold in modern MTG discourse. 💎

Speaking of practical value and cross-promotion, if you’re gearing up for a session or a con badges-and-mice kind of day, a reliable playmat can be part of the ritual. The Neon Gaming Mouse Pad shown above—with its durable neoprene stitched edges—offers the kind of comfort a spell slinger appreciates during long matches. Ready to upgrade your desk while you draft? Neon Gaming Mouse Pad 9x7 Neoprene Stitched Edges

More from our network


Cruel Feeding

Cruel Feeding

{B}
Instant

Strive — This spell costs {2}{B} more to cast for each target beyond the first.

Any number of target creatures each get +1/+0 and gain lifelink until end of turn. (Damage dealt by a creature with lifelink also causes its controller to gain that much life.)

ID: a53624ee-2925-4a56-8706-e278db5d963d

Oracle ID: ef60bb5b-7cf5-4b4d-a725-4531fc0c852a

Multiverse IDs: 380389

TCGPlayer ID: 82361

Cardmarket ID: 266703

Colors: B

Color Identity: B

Keywords: Strive

Rarity: Common

Released: 2014-05-02

Artist: Jason A. Engle

Frame: 2003

Border: black

EDHRec Rank: 23724

Penny Rank: 13707

Set: Journey into Nyx (jou)

Collector #: 64

Legalities

  • Standard — not_legal
  • Future — not_legal
  • Historic — not_legal
  • Timeless — not_legal
  • Gladiator — not_legal
  • Pioneer — legal
  • Modern — legal
  • Legacy — legal
  • Pauper — legal
  • Vintage — legal
  • Penny — legal
  • Commander — legal
  • Oathbreaker — legal
  • Standardbrawl — not_legal
  • Brawl — not_legal
  • Alchemy — not_legal
  • Paupercommander — legal
  • Duel — legal
  • Oldschool — not_legal
  • Premodern — not_legal
  • Predh — not_legal

Prices

  • USD: 0.04
  • USD_FOIL: 0.15
  • EUR: 0.08
  • EUR_FOIL: 0.16
  • TIX: 0.05
Last updated: 2025-12-08