Image courtesy of Scryfall.com

Top-Deck Frequencies in Commander: a closer look with Pilfer

In the sprawling, singleton chaos of Commander, predicting what your opponents will draw next is part art, part math, and part storytelling. The top of the library—what you might draw next—drives tempo, protects key synergies, and often decides who gets to swing the most lethal turns. When you pair this with a card like Pilfer from Foundations, you’re not just playing a discard spell; you’re actively shaping the perceived probability of the next draw for everyone at the table 🧙‍♂️🔥. Pilfer costs {1}{B}, a lean two-mana black sorcery, and in a rarity that’s as common as a well-timed duress in a busy pod, it asks a simple question: what if you could answer a single, crucial card the moment your opponent shows you their hand?

Pilfer’s exact text—Target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a nonland card from it. That player discards that card—speaks to the heart of hand disruption. It’s not a global draw-cut or a mass discard; it’s surgical. In Commander, where a single card can tilt a whole game, removing a key interaction, ramp spell, or combo piece from an opponent’s hand can redefine the likelihood landscape of draws over the next several turns. The flavor text—To the merchant, it was nothing more than a few missing trinkets. To Tinybones, it was the greatest heist of all time.—gives Pilfer a wink-wink vibe: black’s edge, misdirection, and a little heist energy 🍷⚔️.

When we talk about top-deck frequencies, think in terms of three pillars: the probability of drawing your own plan-through cards, the probability of opponents hitting their crucial stoppers, and how often disruption lands to reshape the post-draw landscape. Pilfer sits squarely in the disruption camp, pressing your adversaries to show their immediate resources while you selectively prune a nonland card that might have been landed in their top-deck window. It’s not about exiling every counter; it’s about shaving the edges of what could appear on top of the deck next turn. That targeted discard can subtly nudge the top-deck odds in a way that’s felt, but not flashy—like a quiet, confident heist in a candlelit bazaar 🎨🎲.

A tiny card, a big ripple

Pilfer doesn’t need to maul a board to matter. In a pod where two or three players are racing to assemble a key combo or an engine, removing a single, on-theme answer from someone’s hand can stall a turn or two, which compounds into a noticeable shift in top-deck pressure across the table.

Why Pilfer shines in black-centric Commander shells

Black decks in Commander love to shape the game through control, knowledge, and inevitability. Pilfer’s {1}{B} cost is easily slotted into many early-game lines, and its effect scales with the power of information. Knowing what your opponents are keeping in hand—whether it’s a wheel, a protective counter, or that one-off win-combo piece—lets you decide which card to yank from the flow. In terms of top-deck frequency, you’re reducing variance by pruning a nonland card that could otherwise reappear as a threatening top-deck in a few draws. The card’s Foundations roots also mean it’s a solid, widely available option for players who want a reliable action that rewards precise decision-making without overcommitting to meme-level chaos 💎⚔️.

Strategically, Pilfer blends well with other discard effects, hand-attack accelerants, and المبارات synergy pieces across black, from classic Thoughtseize-style pressure to newer-styled hand-hate that rewards careful sequencing. It’s also a useful instrument when you’re trying to keep another player from sprinting into a pivotal top-deck that would flip the table. The cost-to-impact ratio is favorable; you’re paying two mana to push a moment of friction that can cascade into future draws and decisions 🧙‍♂️🔥.

Deck-building notes: maximizing top-deck control with Pilfer

• Goldilocks disruption: Pair Pilfer with other selective discard effects to force misplays or remove specific threats from hand that would otherwise anchor a turn of heavy top-deck pressure.
• Political leverage: In multi-player tables, Pilfer can be used to signal intent and negotiate truce-like behavior. A well-timed discard can deter opponents from overextending on top-deck turns, creating space for you to pounce later (and yes, this is where the social layer shines as brightly as the play). 🔥
• Protection and timing: Because Pilfer targets a nonland card, you can choose to remove a critical mana rock or a key tutor if it’s in hand. The timing matters: you don’t want to burn it on a card you’ll draw anyway; you want to strike when the draw window is hottest, just after a player reveals their hand 👀🎯.
• Combo-landscapes: In decks leaning into combos, Pilfer can be a quiet countermeasure—ensuring an opponent doesn’t simplify their path to a top-deck tutor or a double-snap play on the next turn.

From a design perspective, Pilfer embodies Foundations’ crisp, affordable disruption. Its rare presence in a common slot makes it a go-to staple for many black commanders who want reliable interaction without breaking the bank. The art by Pauline Voss—though not a marquee mythic—fosters the quiet confidence of a heist master, a mood that fits perfectly with a strategy built around reading the table and deciding which card to erase from the board of possibilities. The card’s black frame and classic layout keep it accessible to newer players while still delivering meaningful choices for veterans 😎💎.

More from our network

• Grovyle’s Hidden Ability Turns Battles Under Sunlight
• Commander’s Insignia: A Creative Force for Player Agency
• NFT Stats: Pipwing Feathercap from Carinoland Collection
• NFT Stats: 37 from the Magnificent Seven Collection
• Pokemon TCG Stats: Doctor Card ID SWSh6-190